When choosing the perfect birthday cake, there are a few things you must keep in mind. These things include the flavour, designs, the celebrant’s taste/preference and the number of guests. Having these details, while you shop for a cake, ensures that you not just pick out something tasty, but that you also find a cake that perfectly suits the occasion.
In this article, Meggscakes and Events will be sharing some of our best tips for patrons in the Newfoundland area who want to pick out a birthday cake.
Factors to Consider When Choosing a Birthday Cake
When picking a birthday cake, there are several factors you must consider to ensure your party doesn’t turn into a total disaster. We have listed them out here:
1. The Celebrant’s Taste and Preference
The celebrant is the most important person in a birthday party, so it’s a no-brainer that you pick a cake that they’ll actually enjoy. Some key details you’ll need from them include their favourite cake flavour. Is it vanilla, chocolate, or red velvet?
If you want the baker to bake the cake from scratch, also ask the celebrant which toppings they like or any special memories involving a particular dessert. This can help you craft the perfect cake.
2. Number of Guests
You want to ensure that there is more than enough cake to go around the party. So having the confirmed number of guests beforehand will be helpful. Calculate the portion size based on the guest list. A single-layer cake can serve a small gathering, while multi-tiered options can work for larger gatherings.
Think about the serving style too; some cakes are easy to serve, while others require careful slicing.
3. Party Theme

The birthday cake should complement the overall party theme. If it’s for a children’s party, then a vibrant-colored cake decorated with superheroes or Disney princesses is ideal.
For an adult gathering, opt for something more sophisticated with minimal adornments. Matching the cake to the theme allows you to create an experience that delights guests and considers the celebrant’s preference.
Dietary Restrictions and Considerations For Birthday Cakes
When choosing a birthday cake, you must consider dietary restrictions and each guest’s needs. These restrictions can be allergies or intolerances.
The types of cakes you can choose when catering to a guest list with dietary restrictions include:
- Gluten-free cakes for people with gluten sensitivity or celiac disease.
- Dairy-free and vegan options for people avoiding animal products.
- Cakes made with natural sweeteners or whole ingredients, and not artificial sweeteners.
Accommodating people’s dietary needs ensures that everyone can partake in the celebrations. Additionally, communicate those needs to the baker or cake shop.
Creative Birthday Cake Ideas

Add a fun twist to your birthday celebration by picking out a creative and unique cake. You can achieve this by using unconventional flavours such as Kiwi, Lavender, Lemon, Coconut, herbs or cheese.
Another way to elevate a cake’s creativity is by using innovative designs. These include multi-flavoured cakes with a different flavour for each layer. Sculpted cakes, which can be moulded into any shape, are trending too; some shapes you can try include the celebrant’s favourite book or a cake modelled after Bilbo Baggins ’ home in The Hobbit.
Consider adding interactive elements to the cakes as well, such as candy, hidden layers, edible glitter, or vibrant colours. Choosing unique and interactive ideas ensures you create a lasting impression with your birthday cake.
How To Choose The Perfect Birthday Cake in 3 Steps
There’s a lot of detail that goes into choosing the perfect birthday cake. Every flavour, layer, design and size must be intentional. To the untrained shopper, this may seem like an impossible feat, but it’s not.
This section covers how to choose a birthday cake in 3 steps.
1. Choose The Right Size of Cake
One of the most important steps in choosing a birthday cake is to get the right size. You don’t want to pick something too small or a cake that can feed an entire village. A good rule of thumb is to pick something that matches the gathering.
Here’s a table that can help:
| Gathering | People | Cake Size | Layers |
| Small | 6-10 | 6 inches | Single tier |
| Medium | 10 – 15 | 6 inches | 4 layers |
| Large | 30 – 40 | Large sheet cake |
You can send an email if you’re unsure of the cake size to buy. We can guide you on the cake size you should get and the number of servings.
2. Be Creative With Designs and Decorations
Creativity in design and decorations adds a personal touch to the party. You want to pick a cake design that reflects the celebrant’s interests or marks a special milestone.
These are some designs and decorations to try:
Sophisticated Cake Designs
Sophisticated cake designs are perfect for adult birthday parties. Decorate with minimalist cream finishes, pastel tones, and light adornments.
Cream Cakes
Pick a cake made with buttercream or cheese, and decorated with modern textures and soft gradients.
Themed Cakes

For children’s birthday parties, match the cake with ocean themes, Disney princesses, or Doc McStuffins. You can decorate with edible glitter or handcrafted figures like kittens, stars, or hearts.
Number Shaped Cakes
Number-shaped cakes are a classic way to signify entrance into a new age, and are suitable for both kids’ and adult parties. Make your number-shaped cake stand out by using a different flavour for the numbers, if the celebrant is turning 10, 20, 65, etc.
Bento Cakes
Bento cakes often have humorous messages written on them and can serve a smaller gathering. You can customise them however you want for your party.
4. Match The Cake To Your Guest List
Matching a birthday cake to your guest list is a sure way to buy the perfect cake. For children’s parties, go with themed cakes. But a cake that shows favourite hobbies or marks milestone ages for teen parties.
Adult birthday parties have a more mature audience, so get something that reflects that. You can pick an elegant floral design, ganache, or fruit cake.
Where To Find The Best Birthday Cakes In Newfoundland
If you’re looking for where to buy cakes in Newfoundland, you can order from Meggscakes and Events. We have a wide selection of flavours for you to choose from, and we take custom orders. Our cakes come in different sizes: 4, 6, 7, 8, and 10 inches.